The Best Diners in New York City
New York might be home to some of the world’s best restaurants, but it’s the city’s diners that have long earned a special place in people’s hearts (and stomachs).
Although diners and luncheonettes in the city are becoming fewer and farther between—often giving way to high rises—there are still plenty of establishments where you can satisfy your craving for greasy food and charming vinyl décor. Below are some top diners you don’t want to miss when visiting NYC.
Lexington Candy Shop, Upper East Side
Chow down to a soundtrack of Heart and Bon Jovi at the beloved Lexington Candy Shop. Continuously operated by three generations of the same family since its 1925 opening, this classic luncheonette and soda shop is where you can enjoy a genuine malted milkshake. The ‘Be Nice or Leave’ sign hanging above the cashier perfectly captures the vibe here.
Tom’s Restaurant, Prospect Heights
While its namesake on the Upper West Side draws a crowd because of its fame in Seinfeld, the Brooklyn-based Tom’s Restaurant has developed a loyal following of its own. Known for enormous pancakes, crab cakes, French toast, and huevos rancheros, it’s no surprise that the line for a seat at Tom’s can often be lengthy—however, it’s definitely worth the wait.
Waverly Diner, West Village
A craving for greasy comfort food can strike at any hour, and this 24-hour diner has been a cherished hangover cure for West Village locals for decades. Offering a delightful range of Greek and Italian-inspired dishes, Waverly Diner also boasts a respectable selection of craft beers, wines, and cocktails, perfect for that boozy brunch.
Square Diner, Tribeca
Although it appears somewhat out of place amidst the wealth and glamour of Tribeca, the nearly century-old Square Diner remains a neighborhood favorite. Its extensive menu features no-frills American comfort food like grilled cheese, pancakes, and corned beef hash and eggs. Be sure to hit the ATM beforehand, as this diner only accepts cash.
Big Daddy’s, Gramercy
This Park Avenue South location is one of the most Instagram-friendly spots, thanks to its colorful decor and extravagant milkshakes. Big Daddy’s also enjoys a playful approach to its menu, which includes whimsically named dishes like Love Me Tenders and Lord of the Fries. Arrive with an empty stomach as the portion sizes here are truly generous.
The Fancier Options
If you love the charm of diners but prefer a more elevated dining experience (and don’t mind spending a bit more), you have several delightful options to choose from.
Empire Diner, Chelsea
Located at 10th Avenue and West 22nd Street, this streamline moderne dining car is one of NYC’s best-preserved diners and certainly one of its fanciest. Known from popular films like Men in Black and Home Alone 2, Empire Diner now serves as a neighborhood staple. Chef John Delucie dishes up modern twists on classic American fare, including sourdough pretzel fried chicken and a pastrami sandwich paired with herbed fries.
Diner, Williamsburg
Tucked near the Williamsburg Bridge, Diner was one of the first reputable restaurants in the area when it opened over 20 years ago. With its upmarket feel, reflected in the prices, this eatery still pays homage to the classic diner experience; servers scribble the menu on butcher paper. Visit this spot if you enjoy pairing your burger with a negroni.
The Long Island Bar, Cobble Hill
The shiny red vinyl booths and glimmering decor transport you back to the 1950s, when this institution first opened. While you might be tempted to sip cocktails, The Long Island Bar is celebrated for its burger composed of two dry-aged beef patties, accompanied by fried cheese curds served with French onion dip.
Discovering the best diners in New York City presents an opportunity to immerse yourself in the nostalgic and vibrant atmosphere while relishing delicious comfort food. Whether you prefer classic greasy dishes or elevated diner fare, NYC has something to satisfy every appetite.
