The Best Hawaiian Islands According to iBestTravel Readers

Hawaii has been a popular tropical getaway for decades — and with good reason. The 50th state’s six main islands — Oahu, Maui, Hawaii, Kauai, Lanai, and Molokai — offer incredibly diverse experiences, from world-class surfing and snorkeling to vibrant food and hotel scenes. These offerings are attracting a new generation of travelers while giving longtime visitors a fresh perspective with each trip.

Every year, iBestTravel invites readers to weigh in on their travel experiences with the World’s Best Awards. Readers evaluate islands based on various factors including activities and sights, natural attractions and beaches, quality of food, friendliness, and overall value.

For the sixth consecutive year, Maui has received top honors from iBestTravel readers, many of whom return year after year. One longtime fan commented on the diverse activities available, highlighting everything from “the incredibly scenic road to Hana to the adventures of whale-watching and snorkeling in pristine waters.”

1. Maui – Score: 89.17

Readers love Maui for its limitless options for outdoor and culinary adventures, from the glistening sands of Wailea and Kapalua to the bustling town of Lahaina. One contributor remarked, “There’s so much to do on this heavenly island; water sports, hiking, and good food are available around every corner. It’s the closest place to heaven on earth!”

2. Kauai – Score: 88.72

The “Garden Isle” of Kauai is known for its lush jungle landscapes and relaxed pace of life. One reader highlighted the old-school aloha spirit present among the locals, and another reveled in “nearly deserted beaches that look like a film set.”

3. Hawaii, the Big Island – Score: 87.42

The Big Island is larger than all others combined, flaunting dramatic moonlike lava fields alongside verdant rainforests and stunning beaches. Hilo, the island’s most populated city with roughly 43,000 residents, features a farmers’ market known for its abundant fresh tropical fruit.

4. Oahu – Score: 85.56

Oahu is a melting pot of experiences, featuring Hawaii’s bustling capital, Honolulu. This city is replete with museums, galleries, and a multitude of trendy restaurants in its downtown area. Additionally, the island boasts some of the world’s best surf, especially on its rural North Shore.

5. Lanai – Score: 82.41

Lanai is an island of tranquility and charm, perfect for those seeking relaxation amidst nature. With limited commercial activity, visitors can enjoy serene beaches and stunning landscapes, providing a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.