Top Hawaii Islands Loved by Our Readers in 2025

Hawaii boasts eight major islands in its stunning 1,500-mile-long archipelago. Visitors often highlight the same five primary destinations as the best among them. Each year, readers from iBestTravel contribute their insights through a survey that collects opinions on the world’s top travel experiences, including cities, islands, cruise ships, and more.

In this year’s rankings, the Island of Hawaii secured the second spot, having earned considerable acclaim from travelers. This enchanting island features diverse landscapes, including lush rainforests, active volcanoes, and magnificent beaches offering an array of sand colors. Visitors can immerse themselves in unique experiences, from luxurious accommodations to budget-friendly hostels.

1. Maui

Maui continues to captivate travelers, maintaining the top spot for nearly a decade. With endless snorkeling, surfing, and whale-watching opportunities, the island’s 30+ miles of beaches offer endless adventure. Equally important is the stunning Haleakala National Park, which features breathtaking views and numerous endangered species.

2. Island of Hawaii

The Island of Hawaii features volcanic landscapes alongside stunning beaches. Travelers are often drawn to its unique geological formations and rich history.

3. Kauai

Kauai is characterized by its lush landscapes, boasting beautiful beaches and a slower-paced lifestyle. It is a perfect destination for those seeking tranquility and natural beauty.

4. Oahu

Oahu is known for its vibrant atmosphere and popular attractions. Travelers can enjoy an eclectic mix of cultural experiences, scenic vistas, and exciting recreational activities.

5. Lanai

Lanai offers stunning beaches and a more secluded experience, ideal for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of larger islands.