by: Barbara GriffinPosted on:

Top-Rated Hotels in New York City: Readers’ Picks for 2025

The best hotels in New York City capture a sense of bygone elegance while offering thoroughly modern hospitality.

New York City is vibrant, with its streets bustling with excitement year-round. Whether you are enjoying ice cream cones in the summer or taking selfies by the iconic Rockefeller Center Christmas tree in winter, the city’s charm is undeniable. After an adventurous day of exploring, shopping, and dining, returning to any of these top-tier hotels provides a perfect opportunity to rest and recharge for another delightful day in the Big Apple.

1. The Lowell

Dining at The Lowell
Nico Schinco/Courtesy of The Lowell

The Lowell Hotel, located in Manhattan’s Upper East Side, exemplifies a perfect balance of subtlety and luxury. Its brick façade harmonizes with the neighborhood, contributing to an intimate atmosphere within its lobby and bar, making every moment spent here feel special. Guests highly recommend this hotel, emphasizing that although it’s not the cheapest option, the experience is worth every penny.

Score: 98.80

2. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

Bemelmans Bar at The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
Don Riddle/Courtesy of The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

Score: 95.27

3. The William Vale

View of NYC from The William Vale hotel
Read McKendree/Courtesy of The William Vale

Score: 95.14

4. The Mark

The Penthouse Atrium at The Mark
Scott Frances/Courtesy of The Mark Hotel

Score: 95.04

5. The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue

A guest room terrace at The Langham, New York
Michael Weber/Courtesy of The Langham, New York

Score: 94.89

6. Public

Exterior view of the PUBLIC hotel and rooftop at night
Courtesy of PUBLIC hotel

Score: 94.31

7. Baccarat Hotel New York

The Petit Salon inside the Baccarat Hotel New York
Eric Laignel/Courtesy of Baccarat Hotel New York

Score: 93.03

8. The St. Regis New York

Royal Suite at The St. Regis New York, Living Room
Bruce Buck/Courtesy of St. Regis New York

Score: 92.79

9. The Kimberly Hotel

A balcony at The Kimberly Hotel & Suites
Paul Gelsobello/Courtesy of The Kimberly Hotel & Suites

Score: 91.90

10. The Plaza

The Plaza Exterior from Fifth Avenue
Courtesy of The Plaza – a Fairmont Managed Hotel

Score: 91.73

11. The Standard, East Village

View of and from the Penthouse at The Standard, East Village
Chris Leaman/Courtesy of The Standard, East Village

Score: 91.33

12. Park Hyatt New York

View from a suite bathroom at the Park Hyatt New York
Donna Dotan/Courtesy of Park Hyatt New York

Score: 91.17

13. Sofitel New York

Sofitel New York Prestige Terrace Suite at night
Courtesy of Sofitel New York

Score: 90.89

14. Lotte New York Palace

The facade and main entrance to the Lotte New York Palace
Dylan Cross/Dragonfly Image Partners/Courtesy of Lotte New York Palace

Score: 90.87

15. The Pierre, New York, a Taj Hotel

View from a guest room at The Pierre - a Taj Hotel
Courtesy of The Pierre – a Taj Hotel

Score: 90.29