Chic Art-Filled Boutique Hotel Opens at Jersey Shore

You can now stay in style just off the Bradley Beach boardwalk.

I dropped my bags, flopped down, and posted a quick shot of the view from my bed to Instagram stories: Eames chair, sculptural floor lamp, huge, striking abstract painting taking up most of the opposite wall. Then, I rolled over and fell asleep.

I woke up to a chorus of DMs: Where??? My friends wanted to know. Some had guesses: Montauk? Hudson? L.A., maybe?

“No,” I replied, gleeful about my secret weekend getaway. “Jersey.”

George DiStefano, owner of The James Bradley, was amused when I told him about the reactions over breakfast later that morning. For him, that initial double-take (Really? The Jersey Shore?) is kind of the ideal outcome.

He spent his childhood summers on the beaches of New Jersey and knows his hotel is not exactly what people expect from this area. It’s a tasteful rebuttal to those who might have preconceived notions based on, say, a certain late-aughts reality show. Moreover, he hopes people who come here often (or have family here, or want their family to visit them) will be pleasantly surprised by the new kid on the block.

The 17-room James Bradley opened in August 2022 just a block from the boardwalk in Bradley Beach, a community of just over 4,000 residents whose population balloons to the tens of thousands in the summer. Built in 1904 as a residential home, the building had been operating as a hotel since the 1960s — first as a hostel, then a party hotel, and most recently as a family-run bed-and-breakfast. Consequently, it was just the second listing DiStefano clicked on.

“I wasn’t really sure what I was looking for,” he remembered, “but once I came across it, it just made sense.”

The deal closed in July of 2021. As DiStefano prepared to shut things down for a 10-month renovation, he enlisted friend (and interior designer) Sebastian Zuchowicki to re-envision the space. “I was apprehensive at first,” Zuchowicki said of working with a friend in a creative capacity, “but the trust between us helped with all of our creative decisions.”

They aimed to balance high-design ambitions with a consciously lived-in feel. “The space kind of blends into the rest of the neighborhood, which is important,” DiStefano noted. “We’ve been so welcomed and wanted to keep the integrity of it.” The more dramatic pieces — angular light fixtures, large pop-art prints — are balanced with lime-washed walls, heavy linens in dusty colors, and other layers of texture to soften the impact.

Together, they sourced furniture and objects from eBay, Etsy, and flea markets as far away as Paris. Some pieces were custom made by local artists, while others were crafted by DiStefano (an occasional woodworker) in the on-site wood shop. Each room is unique, showcasing one-of-a-kind art pieces; mine had a painting by Australian artist Pamela Tang at center stage, just above the headboard. Moreover, many items are for sale, so things are constantly being swapped out, providing a fresh new atmosphere for returning visitors.

“People joke with me all the time, like, ‘What are you doing on your phone?’” DiStefano told me. “I’m looking for keychains; I’m looking for lamps. It literally took me seven hours to find these little water jugs that I’m obsessed with.”

The obsessive attention to detail is something he hopes people will notice. Remembering all the touches he’d appreciated during his own past hotel stays, DiStefano made sure The James Bradley would meet high standards: “Turndown service was important to me. I like having fresh baked goods in the room when you arrive. There’s a signature scent. Little things like that are the differentiating factors.”

Rooms are stocked with toiletries from Flamingo Estate and baskets of locally made snacks; guests can enjoy a transcendent massage treatment in the newly opened spa room upstairs. In the mornings, the airy breakfast room offers a signature blend from Odyssey Coffee in nearby Ocean Grove, fresh pastries and homemade granola, and a hefty breakfast sandwich featuring pork roll (a New Jersey classic). There is no restaurant on site, but custom private dining is available upon request for weddings, events, or special occasions. Furthermore, DiStefano and Zuchowicki are currently working on a redesign for the bungalow at the back of the property, slated to become an exclusive-use rental.

During the summer, guests will have access to a designated area on the beach with lounge chairs, umbrellas, and refreshments. However, rooms were booked up even during my winter visit. A short drive lands you in Asbury Park, a year-round destination known for its vibrant music and bar scene (and the occasional surprise appearance by the Boss himself). The hotel has already gained popularity with couples, groups of friends, and young families, including some new regulars and a few old ones. “One couple has been coming here for 20 years, and their room was always number 5,” DiStefano told me. “She said, ‘It’s OK, you can change our room if you want.’ I felt bad, but they came back to stay in that room last summer and loved it.”

With a reaction like that, DiStefano knows he’s successfully created an inviting retreat. It’s enough to have him contemplating his next project, potentially a bit farther from home. “I’m going to look a bit in Sicily, and then around the Florence area,” DiStefano shared regarding a potential Italy venture. However, he acknowledges that New Jersey is where it all began.