Top 5 Areas to Stay in Sarasota, Florida for First-Time Visitors in 2025

Sarasota, Florida, is a destination that is often overlooked by tourists who flock to Orlando and Miami. This vibrant city sits along the Gulf of Mexico, boasting sprawling white sand beaches and breathtaking sea views. Consequently, if you visit, you will enjoy a fantastic beach vacation without the overwhelming crowds that typically accompany more popular Florida cities.

Sarasota serves as an excellent getaway for travelers eager to engage in adventures beyond lounging on the beach or to simply spend evenings golfing. With luxury resorts, exquisite restaurants, and ample shopping options throughout the town, Sarasota caters to a variety of interests.

This guide highlights the best hotels in Sarasota, assisting you in deciding where to stay while exploring the city. From affordable accommodations near the airport to luxurious beachfront resorts at Siesta Key, here’s everything essential for choosing the perfect Sarasota hotel!

Where To Stay in Sarasota, Florida

Choosing the best area of Sarasota to base yourself largely depends on your reasons for visiting. If you seek a relaxing beach vacation, look for accommodations on one of the islands known for their picturesque sandy shores. In contrast, travelers aiming for a city experience will prefer a more central location, facilitating easier access to major attractions.

Regardless of your choice, here’s a breakdown of Sarasota’s top neighborhoods and their leading hotels to enhance your experience.

Don’t Have Time To Read The Full Article?

• First-Time Visitor: Consider accommodation in Downtown Sarasota or Siesta Key for the premier experience. Noteworthy options include The Sarasota Modern, Tropical Beach Resorts, and The Westin Sarasota.
• Overall Our Favorites: The hotels we loved so much we want to stay there again include Art Ovation Autograph Collection, The Residences on Siesta Key Beach, and Lido Beach Resort.
• Alternate Accommodation: For those who prefer private apartments or condos over hotels, consider Bay Mariner, The Beach on Longboat Key, and Sea Club I.

Where We Stayed

During their stay, travelers Dave and Deb chose the Art Ovation Autograph Collection hotel located in Downtown Sarasota. They appreciated the spacious and immaculate rooms, but the rooftop pool and bar captured their full attention. The views from the pool are nothing short of stunning, making it challenging to leave the hotel and venture out.

Downtown Sarasota: Our Recommendation

Downtown Sarasota emerges as a central neighborhood, particularly advantageous for first-time visitors. It’s brimming with attractions such as museums, historic landmarks, and a myriad of shops. Opting to stay here grants you easy walking access to some of the finest attractions and splendid waterfront views the city has to offer.

This neighborhood showcases some of Sarasota’s oldest structures alongside high-rise condominiums and luxurious hotels. It serves as a great base for travelers who wish to explore the classic attractions of Sarasota while being content to travel a bit to reach the beach.

Pros and Cons of Downtown Sarasota

Pros

• Walking distance to prominent attractions
• Numerous shops and dining options
• Wide range of upscale hotels

Cons

• Limited beach access
• Busy environment
• Higher hotel prices

Highlights of Staying in Downtown Sarasota

For landmarks and tourist attractions, Downtown Sarasota stands out as the premier section of the city. Visitors should come here to admire the oldest buildings, tour remarkable museums, and uncover all of Sarasota’s well-known attractions.

• Marie Selby Botanical Gardens: This tranquil waterfront attraction features tropical flora, serene ponds, and intriguing sculptures. Each season brings unique decorations, with a particular charm during the Christmas season.
• During an evening stroll through Downtown Sarasota, you may encounter the Sarasota Opera House: A historical theatre dating back to 1926, hosting magnificent performances. Even a simple walk past this building allows for admiration of its architectural beauty.
• Bayfront Park: Enjoy sweeping views, whimsical sculptures, fountains, and pleasant walking trails. Families can explore playgrounds while adults unwind at the cozy bar and grill, making for a perfect sunset dinner spot.
• Engaging in a walking tour of historic Downtown Sarasota will immerse you in the city’s oldest segment, showcasing charming buildings, picturesque views, and lovely public parks.

Best Places to Stay in Downtown Sarasota

Downtown Sarasota primarily comprises upscale accommodations, ideal for travelers seeking luxurious lodgings and convenient access to main tourist sites. However, affordable hotels may require a search beyond this central city area.

Embassy Suites By Hilton Sarasota

Embassy Suites By Hilton Sarasota is a four-star establishment nestled in the city center. It features clean, spacious suites comprising a bedroom and separate living quarters. Each room is furnished with a TV, desk, and ensuite bathroom, providing a homely atmosphere.

Guests have access to a fitness center and a beautiful outdoor pool that showcases magnificent views of the Sarasota skyline. Opt for a suite with Sarasota Bay views to soak in ocean sights from your bed, with nightly rates around $600, while standard rooms start at approximately $550.

The Sarasota Modern

The Sarasota Modern is an appealing mid-range hotel in central Sarasota known for its spacious rooms adorned with modern decor and pleasant city views from private balconies. Though some may find the light-colored aesthetics less practical, they are sure to appreciate the hotel’s cleanliness.

Each room includes a coffee maker, ensuite bathroom, and flat-screen TV, with free WiFi access available to all guests. The outdoor pool features loungers, cabanas, and a bar, making it a favored four-star hotel with rates starting at approximately $620 (including breakfast).

The Westin Sarasota

The Westin Sarasota, a three-star hotel located in the historic district, offers almost luxury-level accommodations complemented by a stunning rooftop pool delivering some of the best city vistas.

Adjacent to the pool, enjoy cocktails at the bar while gazing at the skyline. Guestrooms are spacious and modern; amenities include a fitness center and spa, plus complimentary bicycle rentals. Room rates start at about $750 per night.

Siesta Key: Best Beaches In Sarasota

Siesta Key ranks as home to some of the best beaches in the United States, positioning it as a prime hotspot for beach lovers, especially since numerous resorts offer beachfront access.

In addition to its expansive white sand shorelines, this beautiful island boasts a lively center filled with shops, cafes, and eateries. With Downtown Sarasota merely a 15-minute drive away, visitors can easily access the city’s attractions.

Pros and Cons of Siesta Key Beach

Pros

• One of Florida’s premier beaches
• Abundance of shops and dining venues
• Quality resort accommodations

Cons

• Distance from Downtown Sarasota
• Limited tourist attractions on the island

Highlights of Staying in Siesta Key

Though Siesta Key may lack numerous tourist attractions, it compensates with the finest beach in the city.

• Siesta Key Beach: The main highlight, this expansive sandy beach is open to everyone, featuring a beach pavilion, children’s playground, and beach volleyball courts. Certain sections are designated for hotel guests, but the majority remains accessible to the public.
• Siesta Key Village: A delightful spot for morning coffee or evening ice cream. This bustling area blossoms with shops, restaurants, and cafes, with picturesque Ocean Boulevard perfect for casual strolls.
• Siesta Key Drum Circle: Experience a lively gathering every Sunday evening when musicians and dancers unite on Siesta Beach for a thrilling performance, blending locals and tourists that caps off a day at one of the finest beaches.

Best Hotels in Siesta Key

Siesta Key offers numerous condo complexes and hotel resorts just steps from the beach. If you desire proximity to the water, this island is perfect for your stay.

Tropical Beach Resorts

If budget-friendly lodging in Siesta Key is your preference, consider a suite at Tropical Beach Resorts. This three-star hotel offers competitive nightly rates of $350, representing a great deal for the area and is just five minutes from the beach.

The rooms, although on the smaller side and somewhat dated, are impeccably clean and well-maintained, providing value for those willing to compromise on aesthetics. For significant savings—approximately $200 per night—it’s a deal worth taking.

Siesta Key Beach Resort and Suites

For a solid mid-range choice situated in the northern section of the island, Siesta Key Beach Resort and Suites is located on Ocean Boulevard, just a quick walk to Siesta Key Village and another short stroll to the beach.

This two-star hotel feels more like a three-star setting, with comfortable rooms equipped with kitchenettes and private bathrooms. An outdoor pool with loungers awaits just outside your room.

The Residences on Siesta Key Beach

Ideal for families or groups, The Residences on Siesta Key Beach features private apartments that accommodate up to eight guests. Each unit contains a full-sized kitchen, a dishwasher, and a private bathroom. Most units have two bedrooms, suitable for six guests, though larger options are available.

As a Hyatt residence hotel, it boasts various amenities such as an outdoor pool, fitness center, hot tubs, and outdoor lounge areas. Nightly rates commence at approximately $965, which is competitive for a group of six adults.

Whitfield & Sapphire Shores: Best For Cheap Hotels

Whitfield and Sapphire Shores are neighborhoods conveniently located near the Sarasota Bradenton International Airport. These areas are excellent for those visiting Sarasota briefly, providing easy beach access and affordable hotel options.

Sapphire Shores features miles of sandy beaches and superb resorts. Choose this locale for a short stay focused on sunbathing, or opt for Whitfield if you seek budget-conscious hotels with convenient access to notable museums and attractions.

Pros and Cons of Staying at Whitfield & Sapphire Shores

Pros

• Affordable hotels
• A wealth of tourist attractions
• Easy beach access

Cons

• Distance from the Keys and Downtown
• Lack of luxury hotel options

Highlights of Staying in Whitfield & Sapphire Shores

The area boasts an array of Sarasota’s best museums, with the Ringling complex as one of the key attractions featuring a museum, gardens, and the historic home of the circus legend.

• Sarasota Jungle Gardens: This unique animal park nestled in Sarasota Bay allows visitors to roam among flamingos and other native wildlife. The beautifully landscaped gardens provide a serene environment for exploration.
• John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art: One of the most renowned museums in Sarasota, situated in a stunning pink Renaissance palace with 31 galleries showcasing a vast collection of art across various mediums.
• Sarasota Classic Car Museum: A delightful stop for automobile enthusiasts featuring classic cars and some of the earliest vehicles ever made, making it a favorite stop for visitors of all ages.

Best Places To Stay In Whitfield & Sapphire Shores

For excellent hotels with lower nightly rates, consider Sapphire Shores or Whitfield. These hotels typically cost substantially less than those located downtown while providing easy beach access and many leisure activities.

Courtyard by Marriott Sarasota Bradenton Airport

Courtyard by Marriott Sarasota Bradenton Airport is a well-appointed three-star hotel with budget-friendly nightly rates. If you’re only in Sarasota for a short time and want to remain close to the airport, this hotel is a suitable choice.

Features include an outdoor pool, complimentary WiFi, and spacious family rooms. Nightly rates start at about $300 for three guests, a competitive option in Sarasota. The hotel is also conveniently located just a five-minute stroll from the Classic Car Museum and ten minutes from the Ringling Art Museum.

Ramada by Wyndham Sarasota Waterfront

The Ramada by Wyndham Sarasota Waterfront is an economical two-star hotel in Whitfield, differing from the Days Inn by Wyndham Sarasota Bay, which offers inferior service.

Overlooking the marina, this hotel features an outdoor pool suitable for relaxation. Near the premises, you’ll find the Sara Bay Country Golf Club, an excellent option for golf enthusiasts. The rooms are tidy and spacious, with starting rates around $240 for two travelers, breakfast included.

Hilton Garden Inn Sarasota-Bradenton Airport

Hilton Garden Inn represents a well-rated three-star hotel located near the airport. The hotel boasts an outdoor pool, spacious rooms, and a fitness center. Each accommodation is equipped with an ensuite bathroom alongside a TV and desk.

A major perk of this hotel is its complimentary shuttle service to the airport, allowing guests to travel anywhere within an 8-kilometer radius at no cost, which is ideal for neighborhood exploration.

Lido Key: Best For a Mix of Beaches and Tourist Attractions

Lido Key stands as the smallest key off the mainland of Sarasota. Connected to Downtown Sarasota via a bridge, it allows easy access to tourist attractions while being just moments away from stunning sandy beaches.

Select Lido Key to experience a blend of everything Sarasota has to offer, with beautiful beaches complemented by the bustling St. Armands Circle, filled with shops, restaurants, and expansive public parks with hiking trails.

Pros and Cons of Lido Key

Pros

• Ideal for apartment stays
• Close to Downtown Sarasota landmarks
• Beautiful beaches

Cons

• Limited tourist attractions
• Few hotel options

Highlights of Staying in Lido Key

While Lido Key may lack numerous tourist landmarks, it offers a plethora of natural wonders. Its close proximity to Downtown Sarasota adds to its appeal.

• St. Armands Key: Encircled by Lido Key, it serves as the main shopping district, featuring a delightful circle of eateries and shops.
• Lido Beach: The crown jewel of Lido Key, perfect for relaxing days in the sun, swimming, and birdwatching.
• South Lido County Park: Found on the southern part of the island, offering hiking paths, kayaking, and birdwatching opportunities, with a diverse habitat showcasing local wildlife.

Best Places to Stay in Lido Key

Lido Key is a compact island off the coast of Sarasota, connected to Downtown by a bridge, making it an ideal choice for those wanting easy access to city attractions while enjoying beachside bliss.

Lido Beach Resort

A three-star beachfront establishment, Lido Beach Resort boasts two outdoor pools, private beach access, fitness facilities, and three hot tubs. Accompanied by a relaxed vacation ambiance, it undeniably ranks among the finest hotels in Sarasota.

As Lido Key is closest to the city center, easy access to Downtown Sarasota’s popular tourist sites ensures evenings filled with exploring and enjoyment. Room rates begin at approximately $350 for two or three guests.

Casa Limonada Boutique Motel

As a boutique-style property, Casa Limonada provides apartment-style units rather than traditional motel rooms. This choice works well for families who favor apartment stays, complete with full kitchen amenities.

Although categorized as a two-star motel, every unit is well-rated, providing clean and modern accommodations with comfortable bedding. Nightly rates start around $300 for two adults, with apartments accommodating up to five guests.

Holiday Inn Sarasota – Lido Beach

Optimal for those keen on staying close to the beach, Holiday Inn Sarasota features numerous rooms with Gulf of Mexico views, showcasing likely one of Lido Key’s best vistas.

Currently undergoing renovations, this hotel promises an excellent location, with amenities that have consistently received good reviews. Anticipate a rejuvenated experience upon reopening!

Longboat Key: Best For Families

Longboat Key, the largest island off Sarasota’s coast, is celebrated for its extensive sandy beaches, upscale resorts, and golf courses. While it may not host a plethora of attractions, visitors can partake in various outdoor activities to stay entertained.

From cycling to golfing, hiking, kayaking, and swimming, this island serves as a sanctuary for relaxation and enjoyment in the sun and surf. Pick Longboat Key if your ideal vacation revolves around leisure and natural beauty.

Pros and Cons of Longboat Key

Pros

• Numerous resort hotels
• Several golf course options
• Excellent public beaches

Cons

• Distance from Sarasota Downtown
• Limited tourist attractions

Highlights of Staying in Longboat Key

Longboat Key is ideal for those seeking outdoor adventures, particularly for active travelers.

• Golfing: With a multitude of golf courses available, there’s always an opportunity for an enjoyable afternoon on the greens.
• Kayak Rental: Rent kayaks at various locations to explore the mangrove islands, potentially encountering dolphins along the way.
• Joan M Durante Community Park: This locality features walking trails, piers, and playgrounds for family fun.
• Charter a yacht to discover the Gulf of Mexico in privacy, with options for coastal exploration or relaxed days at sea.

Best Places to Stay in Longboat Key

Longboat Key presents many condo complexes, suitable for those preferring apartment-style lodging. Standard hotel resorts are also available but typically come at a higher price compared to apartments.

Longboat Bay Club

Longboat Bay Club ranks as one of the prime family-friendly options on the island, featuring apartments accommodating up to six guests, mere steps from the beach. All units include two bedrooms, full kitchens, and private bathrooms.

Additionally, guests can enjoy year-round outdoor pool access and a children’s playground on-site. Nightly rates start around $500. Divided among six adults, that equates to roughly $60 per person, a fantastic bargain for Sarasota!

Zota Beach Resort

Zota Beach Resort is a stylish four-star hotel positioned in northern Longboat Key. This modern establishment features clean, contemporary rooms equipped with desks, ensuite bathrooms, and flat-screen TVs. Guests enjoy access to a large outdoor pool.

A fitness center, business center, and private beach enhance your stay, while an on-site restaurant appeals to those opting to dine within the resort. Rates start at around $425 for two adults.

Resort at Longboat Key Club

The Resort at Longboat Key Club is an exceptional four-star resort lauded for its luxury. It features expansive rooms with plush bedding, ensuite bathrooms, and kitchen amenities, plus five on-site dining options for guests’ convenience.

Guests can also take advantage of the outdoor pool and exclusive access to Longboat Key Beach. Prices hover around $650 per night, offering quality service that justifies the expense.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is It Better To Stay On Siesta Key Or Sarasota?

Siesta Key is a part of Sarasota and represents the better choice for beach enthusiasts. However, for those focused on exploring tourist attractions and significant landmarks, central Sarasota is preferable.

Which Is The Best Place To Stay In Sarasota?

Downtown Sarasota claims the title as the best location to stay, offering abundant tourist attractions and historic landmarks.

Which Are The Best Beach Resorts In Sarasota?

Top beach resorts in Sarasota include Lido Beach Resort, The Residences on Siesta Key Beach, and the Resort at Longboat Key Club, each located on different islands within Sarasota.

What Are The Best Luxury Hotels In Sarasota?

Luxury hotel options in Sarasota encompass the Ritz-Carlton, Art Ovation Hotel, and The Sarasota Modern, all situated in Downtown Sarasota.