Martha’s Vineyard’s Historic Hotel to Reopen in 2025 with Stunning Pool and New Dining Experience

1. Overview

The Kelley House, a historic 1742 tavern on Martha’s Vineyard, is now part of the hospitality group Faraway. This development marks a new chapter in its illustrious history.

2. New Features

This second property from Boston-based Blue Flag Partners is set to transform the experience for guests, featuring:

  • An outdoor sushi restaurant
  • A new swimming pool
  • A relaxing spa
  • 58 beautifully designed rooms
  • Lush gardens for strolling and relaxation

3. Design Inspiration

Jason Brown, managing partner at Blue Flag Partners, remarked on the importance of maintaining the historic charm of the Kelley House, while incorporating mid-century styling that complements the natural beauty of Martha’s Vineyard.

The design team drew on the island’s 1970s art and music scene as well as a fictional muse, a woman from the 1960s, to create an immersive atmosphere throughout the hotel. The result is a property filled with artistic experimentation, showcasing the potent healing powers of plants.

4. Unique Decor

Guests will find authentic mid-century furniture sourced from antique markets, alongside custom botanical art displayed throughout the lobby. The reception area invites relaxation with a chic sitting space, leather sofas, and a cozy fireplace, all accentuated by vibrant floral arrangements.

5. Culinary Offerings

Returning visitors of the Kelley House will delight in the Newes From America pub, which will feature locally sourced food and drinks. Meanwhile, the Pelican Club, previously a pop-up, will serve as a dedicated sushi restaurant and cocktail bar.

6. Activities and Experiences

The new property is committed to offering diverse experiences, including:

  • Sunset boat rides
  • Barefoot golf
  • Deep-sea and shore fishing excursions
  • Stargazing by Edgartown’s lighthouse

7. Conclusion

Brown emphasized the ambition to create a destination that inspires visitors long beyond their stay. The best boutique hotels connect with their local communities, and that is exactly what is envisioned for this remarkable property.

Nightly rates at Faraway Martha’s Vineyard will start at $695, welcoming guests year-round.

Back To Top