Must-Try Pizza, Pasta, and Delicacies on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx

Introduction

Residents of the Bronx proudly proclaim Arthur Avenue as New York City’s real Little Italy. This vibrant area is a haven for Italian culinary delights and cultural heritage.

The History of Arthur Avenue

Italian immigrants began pouring into the borough’s Belmont neighborhood in the early 1900s, coinciding with the construction of the nearby Bronx Zoo and New York Botanic Garden. They found work in these developments, settled in the area, and opened family-run restaurants and stores along Arthur Avenue.

Today, Arthur Avenue is bustling with many of the same family businesses that thrived a century ago. The pizza-and-pasta-lined promenade is a treat for carb-loving locals and visitors. Apart from legendary specialty shops like Biancardi’s Meat Market and Cosenza’s Fish Market, the neighborhood is teeming with delightful eateries in the form of restaurants and bakeries. Here are some picks for what to savor on your next trip.

Top Restaurants and Eateries

Chicken Francese and Margherita Pizza at Mario’s

Mario’s is a century-old institution on Arthur Avenue, exuding old-world charm with its long banquettes and double table cloths. A must-try is the chicken francese—an egg-battered chicken breast tossed with lemon, butter sauce, and wine. Other delectable options include margherita pizza, calamari fritti, and spinach gnocchi. For more details, visit mariosarthurave.com.

Breadsticks from Addeo Bakery

For over 80 years, Addeo Bakery has been a family-owned fixture, offering fresh Italian breads, doughs, and biscuits. The crunchy sesame-seeded breadsticks are addictive and highly recommended. For more information, check out addeobakers.com.

Pumpkin and Ricotta Ravioli from Borgatti’s Ravioli & Egg Noodles

Borgatti’s specializes in handmade noodles and ravioli, with their pumpkin-and-ricotta stuffed ravioli being a favorite. They offer a variety of flavors and styles, including stuffed manicotti ready to bake. Visit borgattis.com for more details.

Smoked Mozzarella from Mike’s Deli in the Arthur Avenue Retail Market

At Mike’s Deli, you can find freshly made mozzarella, burrata, and delicious Italian sandwiches. The atmosphere is vibrant and engaging, with owner Dave Greco often present. For more information, check out arthuravenue.com.

Fresh Olives from Teitel Brothers

Teitel Brothers has offered fresh olives and gourmet Italian specialties since 1915. Browse their vast selection of pastas, cheeses, pestos, and more. For a tasty snack, try their Italian sweets such as galletti or wafer cookies. Visit teitelbros.com for more details.