It seems almost unbelievable that one could spend an entire day in the wilderness without encountering another soul, all while remaining within proximity to luxurious accommodations and exquisite dining options. However, many of Canada’s islands have managed to maintain their most valuable asset – pristine and unspoiled natural beauty – while enhancing their appeal with award-winning restaurants and resorts.
Top Canadian Islands
Three islands consistently receive high praise from travelers. Vancouver Island and Cape Breton Island are longstanding favorites, but this year, Cape Breton has claimed the top position, followed closely by Prince Edward Island. The charming landscapes of Prince Edward Island, where author Lucy Maud Montgomery set Anne of Green Gables, feature rust-colored dunes, golden beaches, and rolling green pastures. Spanning 2,195 square miles, the island boasts 25 golf courses and a vibrant culinary scene that attracts seafood enthusiasts globally (be sure to check out the September shellfish festival if you love oysters).
Each year, in our World’s Best Awards survey, readers share their insights on travel experiences worldwide – evaluating the best cities, islands, cruise ships, spas, airlines, and more. The feedback helps rank islands based on various criteria, including activities and attractions, natural scenery, culinary offerings, hospitality, and overall value.
1. Vancouver Island
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/pacific-rim-national-park-vancouver-island-british-columbia-canada-02-CANADAISLANDWB18-7f52782176a44d948f4a6e63e240587b.jpg)
Score: 84.59
Vancouver Island encapsulates exceptional leisure activities, whether you’re interested in exploring unique boutiques, taking a boat for whale watching, or hiking in search of cougars, black bears, and wolves. Moreover, for a refined experience, consider making the historic city of Victoria your base and indulge in a proper afternoon tea at the Fairmont Empress hotel. At Cowichan Valley’s Deerholme Farm, diners can savor farm-to-table meals prepared by chef-owner Bill Jones, who also offers mushroom foraging outings and culinary classes.
2. Prince Edward Island
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/argyle-shore-prince-edward-island-canada-03-CANADAISLANDWB18-eea12d2eccec4d10bf03c2d8a62badd3.jpg)
Score: 82.61
3. Cape Breton Island
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/baddeck-light-house-cape-breton-island-nova-scotia-canada-01-CANADAISLANDWB18-cb4ff21cf56e44ecbfdac8fc69f2b171.jpg)
Score: 87.88
Cape Breton Island, nestled in Nova Scotia, boasts a long-standing reputation, appearing on this list for the third consecutive year. It is particularly esteemed for its hiking opportunities; the 60-plus mile Cabot Trail winds through a national park along the coastline. This island is cherished for its friendly residents and rich history, influenced by Celtic, Acadian, and First Nations culture. A reader remarked, “This island is beautiful,” adding, “It’s not overly touristy, which we appreciated.” Another succinctly stated, “Must visit!”
