Top 15 Hotels in New York City: Readers’ Favorites for 2025

Best Hotels in New York City’s Upper East Side

New York City’s Upper East Side is renowned for its cultural richness, housing the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Guggenheim, and other prestigious art institutions. This neighborhood is also home to some of the city’s finest hotels. While it may lack the vibrancy of downtown or the bright lights of Times Square, its manicured charm offers a tranquil retreat amid the city hustle.

Each year, iBestTravel conducts a survey to gather insights from readers about the best hotels, resorts, cities, islands, cruise ships, spas, and airlines. Hotels are evaluated based on their facilities, location, service, food, and overall value. Properties are categorized as city or resort based on their features and surroundings.

This year’s rankings revealed that of the top 15 hotels in New York City, five are situated in the distinguished Upper East Side. These hotels reflect the luxe residential environment, providing spacious rooms, elegant architecture, and personalized services.

1. The Mark

Concierge desk at The Mark Hotel in New York City
Angela Pham/Courtesy of The Mark Hotel

Score: 96.24

More information: themarkhotel.com

Celebrities and designers flock to this exquisite hotel, conveniently located just a block from the museum. It balances elegance and intimacy without feeling overwhelming. The interiors, designed by Jacques Grange, along with top-notch amenities, contribute to a remarkable experience. One guest highlighted the staff’s warmth and the spacious, comfortable bathrooms.

2. The Surrey

Lobby of the upscale Surrey hotel in New York City
Courtesy of The Surrey

Score: 94.76

More information: thesurrey.com

3. The Lowell

Reception desk of The Lowell hotel in New York City
Ellie Pinney/Courtesy of The Lowell

Score: 93.95

More information: lowellhotel.com

4. WestHouse

View of the city from a guest room at the WestHouse hotel in New York City
Courtesy of WestHouse

Score: 92.44

More information: westhousehotelnewyork.com

5. High Line Hotel

View of the exterior of New York's High Line Hotel at night
Courtesy of The High Line Hotel

Score: 91.82

More information: thehighlinehotel.com

6. Crosby Street Hotel

Room at the Crosby Street Hotel in New York City
Courtesy of Crosby Street Hotel

Score: 91.70

More information: firmdalehotels.com

7. The Carlyle

Receptionist at The Carlyle hotel in New York City
Alpha Smoot

Score: 91.14

More information: rosewoodhotels.com

8. The Langham

Guest room at The Langham hotel in New York
Courtesy of The Langham, New York

Score: 90.96

More information: thelangham.com

9. The Chatwal, a Luxury Collection Hotel

Terrace of a suite at The Chatwal hotel in New York city
Courtesy of The Chatwal

Score: 90.83

More information: thechatwalny.com

10. Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown

Bathroom with an egg shaped soaking tub at the Four Seasons Hotel Downtown in New York City
Courtesy of Four Seasons Hotels and Resorts

Score: 90.62

More information: fourseasons.com

11. The Ludlow

lounge area at The Ludlow hotel in New York City
Annie Schlechter/Courtesy of The Ludlow Hotel

Score: 90.25

More information: ludlowhotel.com

12. The Beekman

Guest room at The Beekman hotel in New York City
Courtesy of The Beekman

Score: 90.11

More information: thebeekman.com

13. The Peninsula New York

A vintage Rolls Royce in front of The Peninsula hotel in New York City
Courtesy of The Peninsula Hotels

Score: 89.43

More information: peninsula.com

14. The Pierre – a Taj Hotel

The exterior of The Pierre hotel in New York City
Courtesy of The Pierre, a Taj Hotel

Score: 89.20

More information: thepierreny.com

15. Arlo Nomad

Guest room at the Arlo Nomad hotel in New York City
Courtesy of Arlo NoMad

Score: 89.01

More information: arlohotels.com